blog/

The David Strategy: how to steal talent from Goliath without matching the salary

7 min read
The David Strategy: how to steal talent from Goliath without matching the salary

The email arrives at 4:30 PM on a Friday.

It is from the candidate you loved. The one who aced the technical test. The one who understood your vision before you even finished explaining it. You spent three weeks interviewing them. You moved your budget around to offer them the absolute top of your salary range.

You open the email with hope.

And then your heart sinks.

They are declining the offer. They accepted a position at a massive tech conglomerate. The salary they were offered is forty percent higher than what you put on the table. The signing bonus alone is more than your annual marketing budget.

You stare at the screen. You feel small. You feel defeated.

How are you supposed to build a world class team when you are fighting against war chests that are deeper than the Pacific Ocean?

This is the existential crisis of the small business owner. You want the best people. You need the best people. But the market seems rigged against you.

But what if I told you that you are looking at the equation wrong?

What if I told you that trying to compete on salary is like trying to win a basketball game by kicking the ball? You are playing their game by their rules. And you will always lose that game.

You need to change the game.

You need to realize that while money is a threshold requirement, it is not the only currency that high performers trade in.

There is a specific tribe of talent out there that is tired of being a cog in a machine. They are starving for something that the giants cannot offer. They are hungry for impact. They crave autonomy. They want to feel the texture of the business.

Your job is not to apologize for being small.

Your job is to sell the massive, undeniable advantage of being small.

The Currency of Blast Radius

Let us look at the reality of working for a giant corporation.

It is often boring.

A brilliant engineer at a major tech firm might spend two years optimizing the load time of a specific button on a settings menu. A talented marketer might spend six months getting approval for the font size on a single banner ad.

They are paid well. But they are bored. They are spiritually undernourished because they cannot see the relationship between their effort and the outcome.

This is your greatest weapon.

In your business, the distance between an idea and execution is short. The distance between an action and a result is immediate.

We call this Blast Radius.

When you are interviewing a candidate, you need to explicitly sell this. You need to say something like this.

At that big company, you will be employee number five thousand. If you work really hard, you might move the stock price by a fraction of a penny. If you quit, they will replace you in a week and nobody will notice.

Here, you are the architect. If you build this feature, our customers will use it on Tuesday. If you design this campaign, it will determine if we hit our quarterly goals. Your fingerprints will be on the foundation of this company forever.

Do not underestimate how intoxicating this is for the right person.

High performers want to matter. They want to know that their forty hours a week actually count for something. You are offering them the chance to be a protagonist in the story rather than an extra in the background.

Are you highlighting the impact they will have? Or are you just listing the tasks they will do?

Selling the Speed of Light

Bureaucracy is the enemy of joy.

For a creative person or a problem solver, there is nothing more painful than the red tape of a large organization. The meetings about meetings. The compliance reviews. The political maneuvering required to get a simple project approved.

Your small business is a speedboat. You can turn on a dime.

You need to pitch your lack of process as a feature, not a bug.

Tell the candidate a story about a decision you made last week. Tell them how you identified a problem in the morning, discussed it over lunch, and deployed a fix by the afternoon.

Watch their eyes when you tell that story.

If they look terrified, they are the wrong hire. They need the safety of the herd.

But if they look hungry? If they lean in? That is your person.

You are selling them freedom. You are selling them the ability to move at the speed of their own intelligence.

You can say to them:

We do not have a committee for that. If you think it is the right call, and you can back it up with data, you have the green light. We hire smart people so they can make decisions, not so they can ask for permission.

This level of autonomy is a luxury product. In the corporate world, you have to work for twenty years to earn the right to make a unilateral decision. In your company, you are giving it to them on day one.

That is worth a lot of money.

Access to the Cockpit

There is another hidden asset you possess.

You.

In a large company, the junior staff never sees the CEO. They certainly never learn how the business actually works. They are siloed in their department. They see a tiny slice of the pie.

In your company, they are sitting next to the pilot.

You are offering them a tuition free MBA. You are offering them total transparency into the mechanics of building an organization.

You should promise them mentorship. Promise them that you will open the books. Promise them that they will sit in on high level strategy meetings that they would be barred from in a corporate environment.

Say this to them:

Come work here for two years. I will teach you everything I know about cash flow, operations, sales, and hiring. You will see the good, the bad, and the ugly. When you leave here, you will not just be a better marketer or developer. You will be a business operator.

For a candidate who eventually wants to start their own business, this is an irresistible offer. You are offering them an apprenticeship.

Are you hoarding your knowledge? Or are you using it as a recruiting tool?

The Human Element of Flexibility

Finally, we have to talk about lifestyle.

Big companies have policies. Small companies have relationships.

A corporation has to have rigid rules about time off, remote work, and hours because they are managing thousands of people. They cannot make exceptions.

You can.

You can treat your employees like human beings with complex lives. You can offer a level of flexibility that is based on trust rather than policy.

If a key employee needs to pick up their kids at 3 PM every day, you can say yes. If they want to work from a van in Colorado for a month, you can say yes.

You can say:

I do not care when you work. I care that the work gets done. I trust you to manage your own energy and your own schedule. As long as we hit our goals, you have total control over your calendar.

This creates a debt of gratitude and loyalty that money cannot buy. When you treat someone like an adult, they behave like an adult.

We often think we need to mimic the perks of Google. We think we need ping pong tables and catered lunches. We don’t.

People don’t want ping pong. They want to be able to go to their daughter’s soccer game without feeling guilty. They want to be able to work when they are most productive, not when the clock says they should be there.

Your smallness allows you to be human. Lean into that.

Finding the Pirates

You are not looking for the Navy. The Navy needs structure. The Navy needs pensions and hierarchy and distinct uniforms.

You are looking for pirates.

You are looking for the people who want to go on an adventure. You are looking for the risk takers. You are looking for the builders.

When you are sitting across from that next candidate, do not apologize for the salary gap.

Acknowledge it. Put it on the table.

“I cannot pay you what Amazon can pay you. If you are maximizing for short term cash, you should go there.”

Then pause.

“But if you want to build something. If you want to be the reason we succeed. If you want to learn how to run a ship rather than just scrub the deck. Then you should come here.”

The right person will not just accept that offer.

They will jump at it.

Because deep down, we are all looking for a story to belong to. And you have the better story.

Keep up to date.
Sign up for our newsletter.

We care about your data. Read our privacy policy.

Build Expertise. Unleash potential.

Great teams are trained, not assembled.